According to "Selbyville, our Hometown - Special Publication" of a newspaper, 
The Wave probably, there were 16 homes in Selbyville by 1900.

Pictured with the article was the home of Caleb Murray Simpler, built bef. 1899 
per an annotated photo from "Selbyville Was Founded At corner of Old Indian 
Trail and Sandy Branch published in The Whale, 4/28/1990. I believe the 
annotation is in the handwriting of Dorothy Pepper who is quoted in the article.

Caleb Simpler, farmer  p 19(1 from bottom) 1900 census 
Wm Long, farmer

The commissioners of Selbyville at its incorporation with the state were:
Isaiah J. Brasure
Isaiah W. Long
Robert Hill
Asbury Murray
Charles Hamblin

We can assume that the above men lived in Selbyville and the first four are 
found as head of house in the 1900 census,p21 in this sequence: 
William Tubbs, shoemaker (there is a Tubbs house on Church St., south side)
Issac Johnson, daily laborer
Myers Dunavan, railroading
Thomas Cahall, railroading
Wm Flitchet (sp?), daily laborer
Annie Harper, housekeeping
Isaiah Brasure, blacksmith
Wm Long (this would be Isaiah W. Long), merchant
Asbury Murray, railroading

More to come